Appendix C: Speech Evaluation Competencies and Feedback Forms

Presentation Critique for Audience and Presenter

Presenter: ______________________

Topic: _________________________

Listener: _______________________

Date:_________________________

  • 5 = Exemplary
  • 4 = Excellent
  • 3 = Meets Requirements
  • 2 = Needs Improvement
  • 1 = Weak
  • 0 = Omitted

Critique

5

4

3

2

1/0

Comments

The topic is appropriate for the audience, purpose, and time limit

The introduction builds rapport with the audience, establishes common ground, and leads smoothly to the thesis

The thesis provides a clear, focused topic, and the preview statement identifies three or four specific main points

Clear organization is evident:

  • each main point is stated clearly and developed with details and examples
  • transitions link each main point

The summary restates the main points, and the conclusion provides closure

The delivery showed poise and a focus on topic and audience by using

  • strong, varied use of voice
  • natural gestures and movement
  • audience-centered eye contact

Visual aids are integrated smoothly into the presentation; they enhance the content. Slides are visual rather than text–heavy.

The speaker demonstrates an overall appeal, professionalism, impact, and uses the time well.

Final Score and Overview

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

Just the Basics: An Introduction to Public Speaking Copyright © 2026 by Colleen McGoff is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.

Share This Book